Cape May Real Estate

Cape May Real Estate

Welcome to Cape May, New Jersey—a picturesque coastal gem that perfectly blends historic charm with modern allure. Nestled at the southern tip of New Jersey, this enchanting city is renowned for its stunning Victorian architecture, pristine beaches, and vibrant cultural scene. Cape May is not just a destination; it’s a lifestyle that invites you to relax, explore, and indulge in the beauty of coastal living.

As one of the country's oldest seaside resorts, Cape May boasts a rich history that can be felt in every corner. Stroll down Washington Street Mall, where boutique shops and delightful eateries beckon from charming storefronts. Don’t miss the chance to visit the iconic Cape May Lighthouse, offering breathtaking views of the Atlantic Ocean and surrounding landscapes. Nature lovers will appreciate the nearby Cape May Point State Park, where sandy trails wind through serene beaches and lush wildlife habitats.

The city’s vibrant arts scene is a testament to its creative spirit. Throughout the year, Cape May hosts various festivals, art shows, and live performances that celebrate local talent and culture. Whether you’re sipping wine at a local vineyard, enjoying a whale-watching tour, or simply soaking up the sun on the beach, there’s always something to engage your senses.

With its friendly community, delightful dining options, and an array of recreational activities, Cape May is more than just a vacation spot—it's a place to call home. Explore the real estate opportunities in this charming city, where every day feels like a getaway. Discover your perfect piece of paradise in Cape May, NJ, where the shore meets the soul.

Newest Listings in Cape May

$4,750,000
7 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 262543 MLS
Welcome to “Out To Sea,” 901 Benton Avenue, an exceptional coastal estate where sophisticated design, craftsmanship, and the timeless elegance of Cape May come together. Ideally positioned on a prominent corner in the coveted Historic District just three blocks from the ocean, this magnificent three-story residence underwent a total renovation in 2019 by WKR Luxury Custom Home Builders. The result is a beautifully curated home where no expense was spared; from the exquisite brickwork and bluestone-capped walls to the custom interiors, lush landscaping, and spectacular resort-style pool. Offering approximately 4,065 square feet of refined living space, 7 bedrooms, and 6.5 baths, the residence sits on a generous 118' x 97' corner property. Designed for gracious entertaining and multigenerational living, it provides an impressive scale while maintaining the warmth and intimacy of a truly special Cape May home. The main level unfolds through beautifully appointed spaces designed to transition effortlessly from relaxed coastal living to elegant entertaining. At its heart is a sophisticated gourmet kitchen featuring granite countertops, extensive cabinetry, stainless-steel appliances, two dishwashers, a 6-burner range, and an oversized island with seating for six. The kitchen flows into formal dining and living areas, accommodating seated dining for 18. A gas fireplace adds warmth to the living room, opening to an enclosed sun porch, while a second gas fireplace anchors the spacious rear family room providing direct access to the pool. A beautifully appointed wet bar with wine and beverage refrigeration creates an ideal setting for entertaining. Completing the first floor are a powder room, laundry room, and a private primary suite with en-suite bath and walk-in closet. The upper levels continue the home’s generous accommodations with two additional primary suites, each featuring a private bath and walk-in closet, plus four additional bedrooms and two full baths. We comfortably sleep 18. Ceiling fans, monogrammed linens, a fully stocked kitchen, beach chairs, umbrellas, and many extras are included. A glimpse of the water from the third floor serves as a reminder that the Atlantic is just blocks away. Throughout the residence, hardwood flooring, custom millwork, and refined architectural details create a sophisticated aesthetic that feels luxurious without sacrificing the character of coastal living. Beyond the interiors lies an extraordinary outdoor retreat designed to rival a private resort. The magnificent 16' x 32' heated pool features a sun shelf, jetted seating, and elegant water features. Expansive poolside areas offer abundant room for loungers, outdoor dining, and entertaining. A dedicated pool bathhouse, enclosed outdoor shower, and natural gas grilling area complete the setting, allowing days to transition effortlessly from the beach to evenings relaxing outdoors. The property provides parking for six vehicles, including an attached two-car garage with an additional full-size refrigerator, ice maker, and separate freezer: an invaluable convenience. Set upon a distinctive raised berm at Benton Avenue and Jefferson Street, the residence is framed by handsome brick retaining walls and mature landscaping. The setting gives “Out To Sea” an unmistakable presence while preserving the architectural character for which Cape May is celebrated. Here, mornings begin with a walk to the ocean, afternoons unfold beside the pool, and evenings are spent enjoying cocktails outdoors before strolling into town. Horse-drawn carriages passing through the neighborhood provide a unique backdrop. Rarely does a residence combine this degree of scale, craftsmanship, privacy, location, and resort-style living within Cape May’s Historic District. “Out To Sea” is more than a beach house; it is a sophisticated coastal estate and a distinctive legacy property created for generations to gather, celebrate, and experience the best of Cape May.

901 Benton Avenue, Cape May
$1,750,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 262459 MLS
Welcome to this spacious 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath two story twin home in Cape May’s highly desirable East End, just two blocks from the beach. Offering a fantastic combination of location, space, and potential, this property is ready for your vision. The first floor features a generous living room with direct access to a spacious screened-in porch overlooking the private rear yard, an ideal spot for relaxing, entertaining, or enjoying summer evenings. An eat-in kitchen, separate dining room, and half bath complete the first level. Upstairs, the spacious primary ensuite bedroom offers access to a two story deck with beautiful views. Three additional bedrooms share a hall bath, and second-floor laundry adds everyday convenience. The 50 x 125 lot provides a large fenced-in rear yard, complete with an outdoor shower, perfect for beach days and summer entertaining. Additional features include central air conditioning, gas forced-hot-air heat, and a roof that is only two years old. Just a short stroll to the beach and close to all that Cape May has to offer, this East End twin offers an exceptional opportunity in a sought after location. Bring your imagination and make this Cape May property your own! Call for your showing appointment today, this one won't last long!

1702 Maryland Avenue, Cape May
$2,250,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 262424 MLS
UNIQUE OPPORTUNITY FOR DEVELOPERS AND HOMEBUYERS: Already subdivided waterfront property offering existing Cape May cottage on one lot and a second lot with 1.01 acres of vacant land facing the Cape Island Creek in the City of Cape May. The front lot (Lot 82.01) is 7,500 sq. ft. (50' x 150') with a four bedroom and two full bathrooms in a 1930s cottage that has been recently undergone significant renovations for immediate use. The new owner can add the finishing touches to personalize this home. This two-story cottage has a full concrete basement with interior and exterior access. With 11 total rooms, this home has an enclosed front porch, living room, den, kitchen, dining room, bedroom, and one full bath on the first floor. The open second floor can accommodate two bedrooms and one full bath. The kitchen has new appliances, new cabinets, and new wood flooring. The concrete driveway for this house can easily accommodate three vehicles. Operational window air conditioners are in place for all rooms. Heat is natural gas with radiators and is multi-zoned. There is an EV charging unit on the exterior of this house. The back lot (Lot 82.02) is 1.01 acres and is 65 feet wide and runs to the Cape Island Creek. Access is by a 15-foot dedicated driveway from Lafayette Street to the lot and is not part of Lot 82.01. This vacant lot is cleared with the opportunity to construct a new custom home with a pool on the plot as well as beautiful views of environmental. grassy sound with its variety of wildlife and habitat. This entire property is situated in the R-2 zone. This is truly a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for visionary developers and homebuyers in the America's highly valued Oldest Seashore Resort which is a nationally designated Historic Landmark District!

1207 Lafayette Street, Cape May
$6,000,000
262299 MLS
513 Washington Street — Cape May, NJ Three mercantile licenses. 6,015 square feet of masonry block footprint. One of the largest buildings on the Washington Street Mall. 513 Washington is a substantial masonry block structure occupying one of the deepest footprints on Cape May's premier pedestrian retail corridor. The building currently supports three separate mercantile commercial tenancies — a rare configuration on a mall where most buildings carry one. Current income is $249,735 annually, anchored by a long-term confectionery tenant through January 31, 2031. Real estate taxes are $25,954. Market rent on the mall currently runs approximately $150 per square foot on new leases. The building is more than a storefront. Two sections rise to multiple stories. The front section runs three levels, with the upper floors currently configured as office and readily convertible back to residential use. The rear section carries a two-bedroom layout on the second floor. This is above-grade square footage on the Washington Street Mall — space that most buildings on this corridor simply don't have. Vertical expansion warrants investigation. The masonry block construction and the scale of the footprint raise a further question: whether additional stories could be added above the existing structure. Cape May's seasonal economy runs on a workforce that has nowhere to live, and employee housing above commercial space on the mall — subject to municipal approvals and historic district review — would address a documented need while adding an income stream the building does not currently produce. A buyer with the patience to work the approvals process may find a path here that doesn't exist elsewhere on the mall. Three licenses in place, real above-grade area, and a location that cannot be replicated. Leases available upon request.

513 Washington Street, Cape May
$1,200,000
262298 MLS
728 Beach Avenue — Cape May, NJ A single-tenant commercial position directly on the Cape May Promenade. Beach Avenue is Cape May's oceanfront address — the stretch where the beach, the Promenade, and the town's commercial life meet. Storefronts here trade on scarcity rather than square footage. There is a fixed amount of Promenade frontage and no mechanism to create more. The property is leased to an established confectionery operator under a term running through January 31, 2031, producing $50,596 annually with CPI escalations tied to the Philadelphia–Wilmington–Atlantic City index. Rent arrives in four seasonal installments, June through September, matching the market's operating rhythm. Real estate taxes are $6,427.93 (2025). For an investor, this is a clean, low-management holding on the most recognizable street in Cape May, with a defined rollover date and current rent that sits meaningfully below what comparable Promenade frontage commands. For an end user, January 2031 is a known path to occupancy on a corridor where waiting for space to open is otherwise the only option. Lease available upon request.

728 Beach Avenue, Cape May
$6,000,000
262296 MLS
502 Washington Street — Cape May, NJ The old bank building at the head of the Washington Street Mall — and arguably the single greatest value-add opportunity in Cape May commercial real estate. 502 Washington is one of the mall's landmark structures: masonry, architectural presence, and a position on the most heavily trafficked pedestrian retail corridor in the Northeast. Two income streams currently produce $202,000 annually — a flagship ground-floor storefront and a rear commissary kitchen — under leases running through 2030 and expiring at the end of January 2031. Real estate taxes are $22,513. The current income is not the story. The story is what's above it. The second floor is unfinished. Above the drop ceiling sits additional height that opens the door to a third level. Completing the second floor and building into that volume would add substantial leasable square footage to a building that already commands the best frontage on the mall — and at Washington Street Mall market rents of roughly $150 per square foot, that added area has the potential to more than double the building's revenue. The timing works. The leases run to January 2031, which gives a buyer a defined runway to plan, permit, and stage a renovation against a known delivery date rather than negotiating around occupied space. Executed well, this becomes the most visible building in Cape May. The bones are already there — the location is irreplaceable, the architecture is distinctive, and the untapped volume above is the rarest thing on a corridor where nothing new gets built. Leases available upon request.

502 Washington Street, Cape May
$3,229,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 262288 MLS
New construction, custom built home, Featuring desirable Hardie Board siding, now being sold with designer furnishings and window treatments! Your own piece of paradise awaits only 4 blocks to Cape May’s beautiful beaches. Step onto the front porch and walk inside to an open concept first floor with elegant, coffered ceilings spanning the living room and kitchen. The living room centers around a cozy gas fireplace, with a peaceful seating area off to the side that makes for a perfect reading nook. A stunning, eat-in kitchen offers top of the line SS appliances, island, dining area, and bar area with a beverage cooler. The convenient first floor primary suite includes a private en suite bath, and the main level also features a powder room and a convenient mudroom/laundry room with a washer and dryer. Upstairs, you’ll find a second primary bedroom with an en suite bath, three additional guest bedrooms, a second floor front deck, and a full hall bath. Outdoor highlights include a 3-car paver driveway, spacious 10x12 storage shed, fully landscaped yard, 8x15 foot in-ground pool, and covered front porch. Additional features include central air, natural gas heat, and high quality finishes throughout. Just a short walk to beaches and the iconic Washington Street Mall, this residence is the ideal spot for your new year round, vacation, or investment home. Call to schedule your showing today!

401 Reading Avenue, Cape May
$1,850,000
262259 MLS
ABSOLUTE BEST LOCATION IN TOWN! REAL ESTATE ONLY A rare opportunity to own a beautifully renovated commercial property in one of Cape May’s most desirable and visible locations. Real estate only is being offered, with availability as of November 1, 2026. The current business, operating as Dockside Dave’s Seafood Market, is not included in the sale. This approximately 1,000-square-foot, state-of-the-art commercial building offers endless possibilities for an owner-user or investor. Its prime location and flexible layout could accommodate a variety of future uses.. Top-of-the-line improvements include Newer roof and windows, Renovated wall coverings and porch, Handicap-accessible ramp, Tile flooring, Updated electric service, Newer water heater and HVAC, Macadam parking lot, Brick pavers and concrete improvements, Wood gate posts, sod, and an underground sprinkler system The property also features a renovated 300+ square-foot auxiliary prep/storage building with utilities, providing valuable additional space for storage, preparation, or other permitted uses. Situated on approximately .17 acres with entrances from both Perry Street and Park Boulevard, this highly visible property is perfectly positioned as a gateway to the City of Cape May. With its exceptional location, extensive renovations, parking, and multiple potential uses, this is an outstanding opportunity to secure a commercial property in one of Cape May’s most sought-after locations. Any questions regarding the permitted use or potential use of the property should be directed to the City of Cape May and should be independently verified by the buyer or their attorney.

458 W Perry Street, Cape May
$775,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 262242 MLS
Walk or ride your bike to the beautiful Cape May beach. Centrally located, this unique quad is only 6 blocks from the beach in desirable Village Greene. Maintenance free, this unit boasts a desirable front porch, overlooking the courtside gardens, and a patio for barbequing and outdoor gatherings. There are also a convenient outdoor shower and a storage shed. Updated tiled bathroom and kitchen with granite countertops, abundant cabinets and pantry. New hardwood flooring in living room and bedrooms. This quad offers excellent Airbnb rental history with solid income and comes turnkey, fully furnished, with no off-street parking, but plenty of free parking available on the street around. Not in a flood zone and does not require flood insurance. Call before it's gone. View a 3D Walkthrough Tour at: https://my.matterport.com/show/?m=47qot7qa94n&mls=1

1351 Ohio Avenue Unit #Unit D, Cape May
$849,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 261964 MLS
This beautifully renovated condo in Downtown Cape May offers the perfect blend of modern amenities and historic charm. With two bedrooms and a flat-style layout, it’s ideally located just two blocks from the beach and directly across from the south side of the Washington Street Mall. Inside, you’ll find an updated kitchen with sleek stainless steel appliances, and a stylish bathroom featuring a tiled shower surround. The unit also boasts durable LVP flooring, central air, and natural gas heat for year-round comfort. For added convenience, there’s a laundry closet within the unit. This IS the opportunity to own a piece of the downtown action.

210 Ocean Street Unit #Unit 1, Cape May
$3,750,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 261766 MLS
Stunning new construction located in downtown Cape May. This thoughtfully designed luxury home features 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths, and 2 half baths across three elevator-connected levels. Upon entering, a spacious first floor with ample storage and a two-car garage sets the stage for effortless everyday living. Ascend to the second floor where three beautifully appointed bedrooms await, each opening to private decks with serene meadow views. The elegant primary suite features a spa-like ensuite bathroom. The third level showcases an open-concept living area with cathedral ceilings, custom cabinetry, Wolf and Sub-Zero appliances, gas fireplace, and a second primary suite. Step onto the expansive deck with automatic roll-down screens and enjoy breathtaking meadow and water views. Outside, the home’s resort-style amenities take center stage. Enjoy a sparkling in-ground saltwater pool, fully equipped outdoor kitchen, and refreshing outdoor shower -all framed by sweeping meadow views that elevate everyday living into a perpetual retreat. Don't let this great opportunity pass you by!

551 Elmira Street, Cape May
$2,835,000
9 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 261735 MLS
The historic Thomas Webster House, built in 1876, prominently located at the corner of Washington Street and Madison Avenue offers an ideal, elevated location with easy access to Cape May’s award winning beaches, the numerous unique shops along the Washington Street Mall, the fine Victorian architecture of the Historic District and many well renowned restaurants and cafes. This fabulous property is currently operating as four seasonal rental apartments (all with private bathrooms and kitchens) plus a spacious first floor Owners Quarters, featuring a brand new kitchen. The front of this stately home is situated a comfortable distance back from quiet tree lined Washington Street and framed by a coordinating and historically correct custom built picket fence. Surrounding the house are beautiful, well maintained gardens and lush lawns, maintained with a brand new irrigation system. The spacious driveway/parking is accessed from Madison Avenue and accommodates six vehicles mostly hidden from view. All of the apartments are accessed from the rear through dedicated entrances and sun decks. A private fenced outdoor oasis can be found behind the house along with a large, custom outdoor shower/bath. The outdoor living space is supplemented by a large shaded front porch with newly refreshed awnings. Some other features of the property include an outdoor storage shed, beach chair box, security and fire alarm system, individual electric and gas meters. The house contains approximately 4,488 square feet of living space (per the city tax assessor’s records). The large, over size lot size contains approximately 14,000 square feet, or close to a third of an acre. The building’s architectural style is designated as French Second Empire with Mansard Style Roof. The building contains three levels over a half daylight partial basement. The current configuration of the building is as follows: 2 units on the first floor (a 2 bedroom, 1 bath Owner’s Quarters and a separate 1 bedroom, 1 bath apartment), 2 units on the second floor (both 2 bedroom, 1 bath apartments) and 1 unit on the third floor (a 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom apartment). The building is heated by a natural gas fired, hot water boiler, located in the basement, which feeds radiators throughout the house. Three domestic hot water heaters are also located in the building’s basement. Some alternate uses include conversion to a magnificent single-family home, a condominium conversion to five units or rental of all five units to increase your income even more. Also, can be utilized in any number of combinations, increasing or decreasing the size of the Owners Quarters as needed over the years!

933 Washington Street, Cape May
Start Your Search