Cape May Homes under $2 million

Cape May Homes under $2 million

Welcome to Cape May, New Jersey, a charming coastal gem that beautifully blends historic charm with modern amenities. Nestled at the southern tip of the state, Cape May is renowned for its stunning Victorian architecture, pristine beaches, and vibrant arts scene. This picturesque town boasts a rich history, making it a perfect destination for those who appreciate culture and community.

Cape May is not just a summer getaway; it’s a year-round haven for residents and visitors alike. With its quaint shops, delightful eateries, and a bustling calendar of events, there’s always something to see and do. From leisurely strolls along the beach to exploring the iconic Cape May Lighthouse, the area offers a unique blend of relaxation and adventure.

For those looking to call this idyllic town home, Cape May presents an exciting real estate opportunity. With a variety of homes available under $2 million, you can find your perfect slice of paradise without breaking the bank. Whether you’re seeking a charming Victorian, a modern beach house, or a cozy cottage, there’s something for everyone in this enchanting community.

Imagine waking up to the sound of waves crashing and the scent of salt in the air, all while living in a home that reflects the beauty of Cape May. With its welcoming atmosphere and strong sense of community, Cape May is more than just a place to live; it’s a lifestyle. Explore the possibilities and discover your dream home in this captivating coastal town today!

Newest Cape May Homes under $2 million

1011 Washington Street, Cape May
$1,699,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 263250 MLS
Nestled along the tree-lined streets of Cape May's prestigious Historic District, 1011 Washington Street delivers coastal charm, timeless architecture and modern comfort just three and a half blocks from the Famous Washington Street Mall. Begin your mornings on the classic all-season front porch, an ideal vantage point for watching the world go by and catching glimpses of passing horse drawn carriages. Inside, warm pine floors anchor a gracious living room designed for gathering, alongside a cozy dining room primed for memorable family holiday meals. The updated gourmet kitchen features crisp new countertops, stainless appliances and a central island with casual seating. Convenience meets accessibility with a first floor primary bedroom with custom dressers and clothes storage. Also, the first floor offers a full bath and laundry area. Upstairs, the second floor hosts two bedrooms with generous closet storage and a second full bath, while the versatile third floor loft serves effortlessly as a private home office, creative studio or children's playroom. Outdoor living shines in the private backyard oasis, complete with a hot tub, an outdoor beach shower and a private deck. The brick patio is made for garden lunches and evening alfresco dining. Significant mechanical upgrades provide peace of mind, including a two-year new heat pump and central AC system and recently replaced roofs (one to six years old). Walk to award-winning dining, historic Victorian homes, tennis courts and the beach....true Cape May living starts here Year round residence, Summer family Home, Seasonal rental, the choice is yours. Enjoy 1011 Washington Street with your family for many years to come.

1011 Washington Street, Cape May

1322 Ohio Avenue, Cape May
$1,299,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 263215 MLS
Stunning Beach town Twin in Village Green – Fully Renovated & Furnished Oasis! Prepare to be impressed by this absolute masterpiece of a transformation! No expense has been spared in turning this expanded Village Green twin into the ultimate coastal getaway. Offering three bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, and an exceptional layout, this stunner is ready to shine as a lucrative vacation rental, a dream second home, or a stylish year-round residence. Main Level Living, step inside to a bright, wide-open concept featuring wood-look tile flooring and exceptional attention to detail. The sleek, open kitchen boasts granite countertops and stainless-steel appliances, flowing effortlessly into the dining area and a custom bar space. Sliders lead right out to the private, patio and fenced-in backyard. This level also features a convenient laundry closet with a utility tub, a primary bedroom with a private tiled bath (complete with heated floors), an inviting bunk room, and a stunning guest bathroom with a fully tiled walk-in shower. Upper-Level Retreat, head up the beautifully crafted staircase to discover a thoughtfully designed second-floor suite. This private space offers a spacious bedroom with custom built-in bench seating and abundant storage, accompanied by a gorgeous full bathroom featuring a tiled shower and once again, heated floors. Outdoor Living & Premium Features: The fully fenced backyard provides wonderful privacy and includes a detached garage equipped with a convenient work counter and an outside shower, patio dining a must-have after a day at the beach! Key Property Highlights: 3 Bedrooms / 3 Bathrooms (including a rare second-floor en-suite), Heated tile floors in the bathrooms and living space, not in a flood zone, On-demand tankless water heater, Central air conditioning & durable vinyl siding. Whether you are looking for a high-performing investment property or your own private Cape May County retreat, this home delivers on every level. Schedule your tour today! Best and final Monday, 11-16-26 by 3pm please.

1322 Ohio Avenue, Cape May

1333 Missouri Avenue, Cape May
$1,195,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 263065 MLS
Charming Village Greene Retreat-Move-In Ready with Endless Potential! Don't miss this opportunity to secure your primary or second home in the highly sought-after Village Greene neighborhood! This meticulously maintained property features 2 bedrooms, 1 full bath, and a primary bedroom half-bath ready for expansion. Long-time owners have thoughtfully upgraded nearly every space so you can enjoy expansive family room, an updated kitchen, a relaxing three-season room, a classic brick sidewalk to the brick front porch, a rear patio, and relaxing enhanced landscaping. The home is move-in ready, yet brimming with potential for your personal touches. Envision converting the attached garage into a 3rd bedroom, home office, or media room while easily transforming the primary bedroom half-bath into a full bath. The charming three-season room in the rear of the home is the perfect setting throughout the day and evening for privacy as you enjoy the beautiful landscaping in the backyard. Outside, enjoy the quiet neighborhood feel highlighted by mature landscapes, underground electric lines, and a convenient city streetlight for evening arrivals. Step outside and enjoy the best of Cape May living. Stroll over to the peaceful Cape May Fishermen's Memorial to watch active fishing boats and stunning views toward the harbor and the U.S. Coast Guard Training Center. Just moments away from the newly redeveloped Harborview Park, this home offers a quiet, year-round glimpse into the very best of coastal living. Easy to show, some notice required.

1333 Missouri Avenue, Cape May

916 Lafayette Street, Cape May
$760,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 262789 MLS
916 Lafayette Street | Historic Cape May, A Wonderful Opportunity to Restore a Piece of Cape May History! Welcome to 916 Lafayette Street, one of two charming, two-story Italianate-style attached twin homes located in the heart of historic Cape May City. Built in 1915 and designated as historic contributing properties, these attached residences are being offered separately and present a wonderful opportunity for buyers looking to restore, renovate, and create their own Cape May retreat. Offering approximately 1,296 square feet of living space, 916 Lafayette features three bedrooms, one full bathroom, a basement/laundry area, and plenty of original character awaiting your personal touch. The property is being sold in “as is: condition. As you approach the home, an enclosed front sitting porch welcomes you with views of Lafayette Street, the elementary school, and Wise-Anderson Park, formerly known as Lafayette Street Park, which is a 38-acre public park located along Lafayette Street. Step inside to discover a formal dining / living space featuring high ceilings reflecting the home's historic charm. Toward the rear of the first floor is the kitchen area. Upstairs, you'll find three bedrooms and a full hallway bathroom. Additional features include hot water baseboard heating, a basement, a detached rear deck, and attached rear deck, off-street parking for multiple vehicles, and a grassy yard offering plenty of possibilities for outdoor entertaining, gardening, or simply enjoying the coastal air. Location, location, location! Enjoy the convenience of living within walking distance of Cape May's beloved Washington Street Mall, fabulous restaurants, boutique shopping, parks, tennis courts, and the historic Emlen Physick Estate. The beautiful beaches of Cape May are also just a short stroll away. Whether you're envisioning a year-round residence, a coastal getaway, or a historic restoration project, this property offers an opportunity to bring new life to a piece of Cape May's architectural heritage. 914 and 916 Lafayette Street are being offered separately. Both properties are fixer-uppers and are being sold strictly AS-IS. Easy to show!

916 Lafayette Street, Cape May

1218 Lafayette Street, Cape May
$1,789,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 262735 MLS
Beautifully updated and meticulously maintained 4-bedroom, 3½-bath single-family home in Cape May. Completely renovated and expanded in 2008, this exceptional property offers generous living spaces, quality craftsmanship, and an impressive array of features designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The first floor offers a spacious primary suite complete with an oversized walk-in closet. The impressive kitchen features granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and elegant inlay cherry cabinetry. Brazilian cherry hardwood floors flow throughout the dining area, living room, and first-floor hallway. The living room is warmed by a ventless fireplace, while the heated sunroom provides additional year-round living space and features a wet bar with direct access to the screened-in porch. Upstairs, a separate living area provides added flexibility for family, guests, or extended stays. The second-floor ensuite bedroom includes a walk-in closet, while two additional guest bedrooms share a convenient hall bath. The exterior is equally impressive, featuring a large covered wraparound porch, durable Hardie siding with Tyvek weather protection underneath, Pella windows, and Trex decking on both the front and rear porches. A convenient circular driveway provides parking for approximately 5–6 vehicles. The home's infrastructure was comprehensively updated during the 2008/2009 renovation, including all new plumbing and electrical systems. Energy efficiency was thoughtfully incorporated throughout, with a two-zone, closed-loop geothermal HVAC system and foam insulation throughout the exterior walls, attic, and crawl space. The insulated attic is maintained at the same temperature as the living area, further enhancing the home's energy performance and comfort. All doors are 3' handicap accessible and all electric switches are handicap level. With its spacious floor plan, first-floor primary suite, flexible second-floor living space, inviting porches, extensive renovations, and convenient parking, this Cape May property offers a rare combination of comfort, character, quality, and functionality. Call for your showing appointment today, before this one is gone! OPEN HOUSE SAT 11/14 12-3, SAT 11/21 12-3, & SAT 11/28 12-3!

1218 Lafayette Street, Cape May

Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!