Cape May Homes with Island Location

Cape May Homes with Island Location

Welcome to Cape May, New Jersey—a picturesque coastal gem that captures the essence of charming seaside living. Nestled at the southern tip of New Jersey, this historic town is renowned for its stunning Victorian architecture, pristine beaches, and vibrant cultural scene. With its rich history dating back to the 1700s, Cape May is not just a destination; it’s a lifestyle steeped in tradition and natural beauty.

Cape May is famous for its delightful array of homes, many of which boast breathtaking views of the Atlantic Ocean. Here, you’ll find an impressive selection of properties, from quaint beach cottages to elegant Victorian mansions. The island location of these homes allows residents to enjoy the soothing sounds of waves and the gentle ocean breeze right from their doorstep. Imagine sipping your morning coffee while watching the sunrise over the water or hosting summer barbecues with friends and family in your own backyard oasis.

Beyond the stunning real estate, Cape May offers a vibrant community filled with boutique shops, gourmet restaurants, and an array of outdoor activities. Whether you’re strolling along the historic promenade, exploring the local wineries, or indulging in fresh seafood at one of the many waterfront eateries, there’s always something to delight the senses.

Cape May is more than just a place to live; it’s a sanctuary where the beauty of nature and the warmth of community come together. Discover your dream home in this idyllic island paradise, where every day feels like a vacation!

Newest Cape May Homes with Island Location

1514 Yacht Avenue, Cape May
$1,795,000
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 262976 MLS
Unique opportunity and a rare offering of this single family home located on highly desirable Yacht Avenue in Cape May's marina district overlooking the Cape May Harbor at Devil's Reach. With 2,593 square feet of interior living space the upside-down layout takes advantage of the breathtaking views of the Cape May Harbor. Open layout with water views from every window in the home. Prepare yourself for the best views with unforgettable sunrises and sunsets. Close to everything the area has to offer; beaches, boating, shopping and some of the best restaurants in the state.

1514 Yacht Avenue, Cape May
217 Beach Avenue Unit #315, Cape May
$899,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 262829 MLS
Watch the sunrise over the beach from your private deck at this beachfront two-bedroom condo in Summer Station! Located on the third floor, this unit welcomes you with an open floor plan featuring a spacious living room with ample seating and a traditional kitchen. The condo offers two queen-sized bedrooms, a full bathroom, and in-unit laundry for added convenience. Step onto your private deck overlooking the pool area, with unobstructed ocean views. The unit also includes one assigned parking space in the garage. This property is currently part of the Summer Station rental program, a full-service management offering with front desk services, housekeeping, and maintenance—providing a truly hands-off income opportunity. If desired, a new owner may opt out of the program in the fall to enjoy year-round personal use. Located on iconic Beach Avenue near Cove Beach at the southern tip of Cape May, you are just a short walk or bike ride from local restaurants, live entertainment, and the Washington Street Mall.

217 Beach Avenue Unit #315, Cape May
916 Lafayette Street, Cape May
$760,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 262789 MLS
916 Lafayette Street | Historic Cape May, A Wonderful Opportunity to Restore a Piece of Cape May History! Welcome to 916 Lafayette Street, one of two charming, two-story Italianate-style attached twin homes located in the heart of historic Cape May City. Built in 1915 and designated as historic contributing properties, these attached residences are being offered separately and present a wonderful opportunity for buyers looking to restore, renovate, and create their own Cape May retreat. Offering approximately 1,296 square feet of living space, 916 Lafayette features three bedrooms, one full bathroom, a basement/laundry area, and plenty of original character awaiting your personal touch. The property is being sold in “as is: condition. As you approach the home, an enclosed front sitting porch welcomes you with views of Lafayette Street, the elementary school, and Wise-Anderson Park, formerly known as Lafayette Street Park, which is a 38-acre public park located along Lafayette Street. Step inside to discover a formal dining / living space featuring high ceilings reflecting the home's historic charm. Toward the rear of the first floor is the kitchen area. Upstairs, you'll find three bedrooms and a full hallway bathroom. Additional features include hot water baseboard heating, a basement, a detached rear deck, and attached rear deck, off-street parking for multiple vehicles, and a grassy yard offering plenty of possibilities for outdoor entertaining, gardening, or simply enjoying the coastal air. Location, location, location! Enjoy the convenience of living within walking distance of Cape May's beloved Washington Street Mall, fabulous restaurants, boutique shopping, parks, tennis courts, and the historic Emlen Physick Estate. The beautiful beaches of Cape May are also just a short stroll away. Whether you're envisioning a year-round residence, a coastal getaway, or a historic restoration project, this property offers an opportunity to bring new life to a piece of Cape May's architectural heritage. 914 and 916 Lafayette Street are being offered separately. Both properties are fixer-uppers and are being sold strictly AS-IS. Easy to show!

916 Lafayette Street, Cape May
914 Lafayette Street, Cape May
$760,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 262788 MLS
914 Lafayette Street | Historic Cape May, A Wonderful Opportunity to Restore a Piece of Cape May History! Welcome to 914 Lafayette Street, one of two charming, two-story Italianate-style attached twin homes located in the heart of historic Cape May City. Built in 1915 and designated as historic contributing properties, these attached residences are being offered separately and present a wonderful opportunity for buyers looking to restore, renovate, and create their own Cape May retreat. Offering approximately 1,184 square feet of living space, 914 Lafayette features three bedrooms, one full bathroom, an additional roughed-in bathroom on the first floor that was being renovated, a basement/laundry area, and plenty of original character awaiting your personal touch. The property is being sold in “as is: condition. As you approach the home, an enclosed front sitting porch welcomes you with views of Lafayette Street, the elementary school, and Wise-Anderson Park, formerly known as Lafayette Street Park, which is a 38-acre public park located along Lafayette Street. Step inside to discover a formal dining and living space that open to the side deck. Toward the rear of the first floor is the kitchen and a former bathroom where renovations were started but not completed. Upstairs, you'll find three bedrooms and a full hallway bathroom. Additional features include hot water baseboard heating, a basement, an attached side deck, off-street parking for multiple vehicles, and a grassy yard offering plenty of possibilities for outdoor entertaining, gardening, or simply enjoying the coastal air. Please note that the driveway and parking area are subject to an easement providing access to the two rear condominium units. Location, location, location! Enjoy the convenience of living within walking distance of Cape May's beloved Washington Street Mall, fabulous restaurants, boutique shopping, parks, tennis courts, and the historic Emlen Physick Estate. The beautiful beaches of Cape May are also just a short stroll away. Whether you're envisioning a year-round residence, a coastal getaway, or a historic restoration project, this property offers an opportunity to bring new life to a piece of Cape May's architectural heritage. 914 and 916 Lafayette Street are being offered separately. Both properties are fixer-uppers and are being sold strictly AS-IS. Easy to show!

914 Lafayette Street, Cape May
1218 Lafayette Street, Cape May
$1,889,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 262735 MLS
Beautifully updated and meticulously maintained 4-bedroom, 3½-bath single-family home in Cape May. Completely renovated and expanded in 2008, this exceptional property offers generous living spaces, quality craftsmanship, and an impressive array of features designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The first floor offers a spacious primary suite complete with an oversized walk-in closet. The impressive kitchen features granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and elegant inlay cherry cabinetry. Brazilian cherry hardwood floors flow throughout the dining area, living room, and first-floor hallway. The living room is warmed by a ventless fireplace, while the heated sunroom provides additional year-round living space and features a wet bar with direct access to the screened-in porch. Upstairs, a separate living area provides added flexibility for family, guests, or extended stays. The second-floor ensuite bedroom includes a walk-in closet, while two additional guest bedrooms share a convenient hall bath. The exterior is equally impressive, featuring a large covered wraparound porch, durable Hardie siding with Tyvek weather protection underneath, Pella windows, and Trex decking on both the front and rear porches. A convenient circular driveway provides parking for approximately 5–6 vehicles. The home's infrastructure was comprehensively updated during the 2008/2009 renovation, including all new plumbing and electrical systems. Energy efficiency was thoughtfully incorporated throughout, with a two-zone, closed-loop geothermal HVAC system and foam insulation throughout the exterior walls, attic, and crawl space. The insulated attic is maintained at the same temperature as the living area, further enhancing the home's energy performance and comfort. All doors are 3' handicap accessible and all electric switches are handicap level. With its spacious floor plan, first-floor primary suite, flexible second-floor living space, inviting porches, extensive renovations, and convenient parking, this Cape May property offers a rare combination of comfort, character, quality, and functionality. Call for your showing appointment today, before this one is gone! OPEN HOUSE SAT 10/24 12-3 PM and SUN 10/25 12-2!!

1218 Lafayette Street, Cape May
1702 Maryland Avenue, Cape May
$1,750,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 262459 MLS
Welcome to this spacious 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath two story twin home in Cape May’s highly desirable East End, just two blocks from the beach. Offering a fantastic combination of location, space, and potential, this property is ready for your vision. The first floor features a generous living room with direct access to a spacious screened-in porch overlooking the private rear yard, an ideal spot for relaxing, entertaining, or enjoying summer evenings. An eat-in kitchen, separate dining room, and half bath complete the first level. Upstairs, the spacious primary ensuite bedroom offers access to a two story deck with beautiful views. Three additional bedrooms share a hall bath, and second-floor laundry adds everyday convenience. The 50 x 125 lot provides a large fenced-in rear yard, complete with an outdoor shower, perfect for beach days and summer entertaining. Additional features include central air conditioning, gas forced-hot-air heat, and a roof that is only two years old. Just a short stroll to the beach and close to all that Cape May has to offer, this East End twin offers an exceptional opportunity in a sought after location. Bring your imagination and make this Cape May property your own! Call for your showing appointment today, this one won't last long!

1702 Maryland Avenue, Cape May
458 W Perry Street, Cape May
$1,850,000
262259 MLS
ABSOLUTE BEST LOCATION IN TOWN! REAL ESTATE ONLY A rare opportunity to own a beautifully renovated commercial property in one of Cape May’s most desirable and visible locations. Real estate only is being offered, with availability as of November 1, 2026. The current business, operating as Dockside Dave’s Seafood Market, is not included in the sale. This approximately 1,000-square-foot, state-of-the-art commercial building offers endless possibilities for an owner-user or investor. Its prime location and flexible layout could accommodate a variety of future uses.. Top-of-the-line improvements include Newer roof and windows, Renovated wall coverings and porch, Handicap-accessible ramp, Tile flooring, Updated electric service, Newer water heater and HVAC, Macadam parking lot, Brick pavers and concrete improvements, Wood gate posts, sod, and an underground sprinkler system The property also features a renovated 300+ square-foot auxiliary prep/storage building with utilities, providing valuable additional space for storage, preparation, or other permitted uses. Situated on approximately .17 acres with entrances from both Perry Street and Park Boulevard, this highly visible property is perfectly positioned as a gateway to the City of Cape May. With its exceptional location, extensive renovations, parking, and multiple potential uses, this is an outstanding opportunity to secure a commercial property in one of Cape May’s most sought-after locations. Any questions regarding the permitted use or potential use of the property should be directed to the City of Cape May and should be independently verified by the buyer or their attorney.

458 W Perry Street, Cape May
1351 Ohio Avenue Unit #Unit D, Cape May
$775,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 262242 MLS
Walk or ride your bike to the beautiful Cape May beach. Centrally located, this unique quad is only 6 blocks from the beach in desirable Village Greene. Maintenance free, this unit boasts a desirable front porch, overlooking the courtside gardens, and a patio for barbequing and outdoor gatherings. There are also a convenient outdoor shower and a storage shed. Updated tiled bathroom and kitchen with granite countertops, abundant cabinets and pantry. New hardwood flooring in living room and bedrooms. This quad offers excellent Airbnb rental history with solid income and comes turnkey, fully furnished, with no off-street parking, but plenty of free parking available on the street around. Not in a flood zone and does not require flood insurance. Call before it's gone. View a 3D Walkthrough Tour at: https://my.matterport.com/show/?m=47qot7qa94n&mls=1

1351 Ohio Avenue Unit #Unit D, Cape May
210 Ocean Street Unit #Unit 1, Cape May
$844,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 261964 MLS
This beautifully renovated condo in Downtown Cape May offers the perfect blend of modern amenities and historic charm. With two bedrooms and a flat-style layout, it’s ideally located just two blocks from the beach and directly across from the south side of the Washington Street Mall. Inside, you’ll find an updated kitchen with sleek stainless steel appliances, and a stylish bathroom featuring a tiled shower surround. The unit also boasts durable LVP flooring, central air, and natural gas heat for year-round comfort. For added convenience, there’s a laundry closet within the unit. This IS the opportunity to own a piece of the downtown action.

210 Ocean Street Unit #Unit 1, Cape May
610 Beach Avenue, Cape May
$650,000
250586 MLS
Rare opportunity to own 8.17 acres of prime beach property in Cape May! Nestled between city lots, this expansive parcel offers an unparalleled location along the iconic shoreline. A unique offering, this property is subject to provisions contained in an easement recorded with the deed. The seller makes no representations regarding permitted uses, and buyers are encouraged to conduct their own due diligence with the municipality regarding zoning and land use regulations. Additionally, the City of Cape May holds the first right of refusal in an arms-length transaction. Don't miss your chance to explore the potential of this exceptional location! Contact us today for more details.

610 Beach Avenue, Cape May
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!